[Decision Making] Official Answers for CSAT 2012’s Decision Making QuestionsDevendra Vishwakarma
- Subordinate’s report
- Project review
- Sports chairman
- Project Deadline
- Water supply
- Bad answer
- Good answer
In the previous article, we saw the Decision Making questions asked in 2011’s paper. click me
Now let’s check the 2012’s questions- with the official answer key for CSAT 2012, uploaded by UPSC on http://www.upsc.gov.in/exams/answerkeys/index.htm#PageTop
You have differences of the opinion regarding the final report prepared by your subordinate that is to be submitted urgently. The subordinate is justifying the information given in the report. You would
- Convince the subordinate that he is wrong
- Tell him to reconsider the results
- Revise the report on your own
- Tell him not to justify the mistake
Official answerkey says A or C
Since this report is to be submitted “urgently”.
B or C will only lead to more talking. A or C deliver result.
You are competing with your batch-mate for the prestigious award to be decided based on an oral presentation. You have been asked by the committee to finish on time. Your friend however, is allowed more than the stipulated time period.
a) Lodge a complaint to chairperson against the discrimination.
b) Not listen to any justification from the committee
c) Ask for withdrawal of your name
d) Protest and leave the place
Official answer says A or D
B= arrogance or hot tempered person.
C= withdrawal= shying away= not upright guy.
You are handling a time bound project. During the project review meeting, you find that project is likely to get delayed due to lack of cooperation of the team members. You would,
- Warn the team members for their non-cooperation
- Look into the reasons for non-cooperation
- Ask for the replacement of the team members
- Ask for the extension of time citing reasons
Official answer says A or B
- Just like 1st question (subordinate’s report), this too contains the “time/urgency” element.
- C= Asking for replacement= bad because time bound project.
- D= asking for extension of time= bad because time bound project.
- Thus we are left with A or B.
You are a chairperson of a state sports committee. You have received a complaint and later it was found that an athlete in junior age category who has won a medal has crossed the age criteria by 5 days. You would…
- Ask the screening committee for a clarification
- Ask the athlete to return the medal
- Ask the athlete to get an affidavit from the court declaring his/her age.
- Ask the members of the committee for their views
official answer key says A or D
- A and D=Committee mindset. But then again you’re chairman of the Committee.
- Asking athlete to return medal or file affidavit is like you running the act solo.
- (although looking at the phrase “received a complaint and later it was found”….seems the investigation part is over and now it calls for some action= B or C, but official answerkey is A or D)
You are handling a priority project and have been meeting all the deadlines and planning your leave during the project. Your immediate boss does not grant leave citing the urgency of the project. You would…
- Proceed on leave without waiting for the sanction
- Pretend to be sick and take leave
- Approach higher authority to reconsider the leave application.
- Tell the boss that it is not justified.
Official answerkey says C or D
B= liar = pliable
C or D=upright guy.
You are involved in setting up a water supply project in remote area. Full recovery of cost is impossible in any case. The income levels in the area are low and 25% of the population is below poverty line (BPL). When a decision has to be taken on pricing you would….
- Recommended that the supply of water be free of charge in all respects
- Recommended that the users pay a onetime fixed sum for installation of taps and the usage of water be free
- Recommended that a fixed monthly charges be levied on the non-BPL families and for BPL families water should be free
- Recommended that the users pay a charge based on the consumption of water with differentiated charges for Non-BPL and BPL families.
Official answer key says C or D
- A= implausible/impractical, and more importantly unsuitable given the fiscal deficit issue.
- B= fixed installation charges= difficult for BPL. And later free for everyone = impractical, fiscal deficit.
- C or D=humane, upright because BPL are getting either water free or at a differentiated =lower cost while remaining junta has to pay.
As a citizen you have some work with a government department. The official calls you again and again; and without directly asking you, sends out feelers for a bribe. You want to get your work done. You would…
- Give a bribe
- Behave as if you have not understood the feelers and persist with your application
- Go to the higher officer for help verbally complaining about feelers.
- Send in a formal complaint
Official answerkey says B or C
- A =pliable = bad.
- B= under the assumption that he will do your work for “free” when you don’t reponsd to his bribe tactic.=legit answer (Although doesn’t feel right, because bribe seeker doesn’t quit that easily in real life!)
- C= good enough.
- D= formal complaint won’t help much because he is not “directly asking you”. (although again doesn’t feel right, ACB will never get any cases if people did not come up with formal complaints. And what is the guarantee that “higher officer” in option C will listen to your complaint! May be he too gets a share from this bribe! but then again #officialanswerkeysayso)
Anyways, this ends the Decision Making questions in CSAT 2012, what do we get from this?